You already know that living a healthy lifestyle includes more than clean eating and regular exercise. I firmly believe that you shouldn't have to play an ingredient guessing game every time you go to buy new skin care products. Here are the top 20 ingredients to avoid in skin care products, plus my favorite clean product swaps.
What's the biggest difference between people that feel confident in knowing they've made the healthiest decisions for themselves…and those who find themselves feeling completely overwhelmed at the thought of yet another ingredient decision?
I've been there too. But what I now know is that there's power in knowledge. You should feel confident knowing that you're taking care of yourself and your family, both inside and out, right?
Doesn't the FDA protect me from skin care ingredients I need to avoid?
Did you know that cosmetic ingredients – aside from color additives – do not require FDA approval before they go to market? Or that, in the eyes of the FDA, the term “cosmetic” wraps in items like nail polish, moisturizer, perfume, lipstick, makeup of all sorts, shampoo, perms, hair colors, and even deodorants?
Research has shown that the average adult uses 9 products like these every day, typically totaling up to 126 unique chemical ingredients. And (perhaps more alarmingly) that every day one in 13 women is exposing herself to ingredients that have also been identified as known or probable human carcinogens through those very same skin care products sitting on your bathroom shelf.
While there are certainly many skin care ingredients to avoid, shopping for safer skin care and makeup products can actually be easy. In fact, you don't need to DIY everything you use or give up all the luxurious bath products either!
Here's the truth about safer skin care:
When you know which skin care ingredients to avoid (and which clean beauty brands make safer products), buying healthy products is not only easy but fun!
(Psst! Join my Clean Skin Care newsletter to learn more about how to choose safer products.)
This post contains affiliate links for your convenience. Please read my disclosure for more info.
Here are the top Ingredients to Avoid in Skin Care Products (Plus My Favorite Clean Beauty Product Swaps!)
1. Synthetic Fragrance
This term covers any and all engineered scent agents. These bad boys can contain any combination of 3,000+ stock chemical ingredients (including known allergens and identified hormone disruptors).
Unfortunately, fragrance formulas found in cosmetics are protected under U.S. regulations. Why? Because they remain classified as most likely to be a “trade secret.” This classification allows them to remain undisclosed.
Found in: Practically all types of cosmetics (and other places in your home). If it says “fragrance” or “perfume” in the ingredient list it can contain any of these chemicals – including phthalates (see #2 below).
Safer skin care product swaps: My favorite clean beauty brand is Beautycounter. I feel great shopping their products because they've made a public commitment to a rigorous health and safety standard. All of their products are free from synthetic fragrance and other questionable or harmful ingredients.
2. Phthalates
Phthalates like DBP, DEHP, and DEP are a class of plasticizing chemicals. They make the fragrances in your skin care products stick to your skin or make the product itself more pliable. There is plenty of research that indicates that this family of ingredients disrupts the endocrine system and is toxic to our organs (both reproductive and non-reproductive). They might also cause birth defects.
The European Union has already moved on banning this family of ingredients from use in cosmetics and skin care products, whereas the FDA continues to monitor its use. And while the FDA does require that manufacturers list this ingredient, there is a serious loophole in listing requirements. Why? This ingredient family is used in fragrances and fragrance ingredients are classified as “trade secrets”, so you may also have products that contain one or more undisclosed types of phthalates.
Most commonly found in: synthetic fragrance (so basically most conventional products that are scented), soap, shampoo, deodorant, body lotion, nail polish, hairspray, aftershave lotion
Safer skin care product swaps: charcoal cleansing bar, shampoo, deodorant, citrus mimosa body lotion, nail polish, sea salt spray (for beach-perfect waves), aftershave
3. Parabens
Parabens (including methylparabens, isobutylparabens, proplyparabens, and others) are a family of preservatives that manufacturers use in skin care products to help prevent the growth of bacteria and mold.
There is strong evidence to indicate that this family of chemicals act as endocrine disruptors, meaning that they alter important hormone mechanisms in our bodies. There is also evidence to indicate that this class of ingredients is an allergen.
Most commonly found in: shampoo, face cleanser, body wash, body lotion, foundation.
Safer skin care product swaps: shampoo, cleansing milk (awesome for sensitive skin!), body wash, melting body balm, SPF 20 tinted moisturizer, tint skin foundation
4. PEG (Polyethylene Glycol)
This ingredient is widely used as a thickener and moisture-carrier in many skin care products. You might also find it in your cosmetics as a solvent or softener.
The danger with this ingredient is that, depending on manufacturing processes, it could be contaminated with ethylene oxide and 1,4-dioxane, both of which have a robust body of data indicating that they are carcinogens.
Most commonly found in: creams, sunscreen, shampoo.
Safer skin care product swaps: citrus mimosa hand cream (yes, it smells as yummy as it sounds), eye rescue cream, hydrating sleeping cream, mineral sunscreen lotion, mineral sunscreen stick, mineral sunscreen spray, shampoo
5. Retinol
Retinol is a synthetic form of Vitamin A. You'll find it in a variety of anti-aging skin care products, but “data from an FDA study indicate that retinoid ingredients may speed the development of skin tumors and lesions on sun-exposed skin” (EWG). At the very least, retinol is known to cause skin irritation, photosensitivity, and is not recommended for use during pregnancy or nursing.
Most commonly found in: moisturizers, anti-aging skincare
Safer skin care product swaps: Beautycounter has just introduced a new anti-aging skin care line using a natural, plant-based alternative to retinol. The Countertime line includes cleansing oil, essence, serum, moisturizer, night cream, and eye cream.
6. Formaldehyde
There is significant data proving that this particular ingredient is, simply put, very bad. It could also be lurking inside your cosmetics as a preservative. Research shows that this is a known carcinogen. It's also linked to asthma, neurotoxicity, developmental toxicity and as a general irritant to skin, eyes, and lungs.
It's also a noted impurity in ingredients like quaternium-15, DMDM hydantoin, imidazolidinyl urea, diazolidinyl urea, sodium hydroxymethylglycinate, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1,3 diol (Bronopol), as well as several other preservatives that might be among the listed ingredients in your personal products.
Found in: shampoo, body wash, bubble bath
Safer skin care product swaps: I like this shampoo for daily rinses and this citrus mimosa body wash smells delicious. I also love this relaxing sea salt soak.
(P.S. Beautycounter has promised not to use any of these formaldehyde-related preservatives.)
7. SLS (Sodium Lauryl Sulfate)
SLS is a foam booster and cleansing agent that can cause irritations for your skin, eyes, and lungs. It can also trigger allergies. There are also concerns of it causing non-reproductive organ toxicity as well as being an environmental toxin.
Most commonly found in: shampoo, body wash, bubble bath.
Safer skin care product swaps: shampoo, citrus mimosa body wash, flower bath
8. SLES (Sodium Laureth Sulfate)
SLES is used in a similar way in as SLS, but is also often contaminated with 1,4-dioxane. This is a concern because 1,4-dioxane's primary use is to make other chemicals less harsh. And, as mentioned above, 1,4-dioxane is a known carcinogen.
While the concern for skin, eye and lung irritation is high, there are also significant data gaps in understanding the additional effects that this particular ingredient may cause with repeated exposure.
Most commonly found in: shampoo, body wash, bubble bath
Safer skin care product swaps: shampoo, citrus mimosa body wash, sea salt bath
9. Triclosan & Triclocarban
Both triclosan and triclocarban are antimicrobial agents and preservatives found in skin care products and household cleaning supplies (yuck!). As you might expect, this ingredient causes skin, eye and lung irritation. Research also suggests that repeated exposure causes bioaccumulation.
Both of these ingredients may also be endocrine disruptors and impact both reproductive and non-reproductive organ system toxicity.
Most commonly found in: liquid soap, soap bars, toothpaste.
Safer skin care product swaps: citrus mimosa body bar, charcoal cleansing bar, men's body bar, citrus mimosa hand wash, toothpaste
10. BHA & BHT
These two ingredients are synthetic antioxidants used as stabilizers to extend product shelf life. They are also likely carcinogens and endocrine disruptors. And they may even cause liver damage.
Found in: lipsticks, moisturizers, diaper creams, and other cosmetics
Safer skin care product swaps: color intense lipsticks (I love Backstage and 9 to 5), moisturizers (my favorite is the Countermatch adaptive moisture lotion), calming diaper rash cream
11. Coal Tar
Bet you didn't expect to see this in your skin care ingredients list, did you?
Coal tar is a byproduct of coal processing and it's a known carcinogen, skin allergen, and respiratory toxicant. You can also find it in hair dyes and in anti-dandruff shampoos.
Found in: hair dye, shampoo
Safer skin care product swaps: shampoo, conditioner
12. EDTA (also known as Ethylenediaminetetraacetic Acid)
This is a binding agent added to cosmetics to improve stability and decrease the reactivity of any metal ions that may be present in your products. While it is listed with a relatively low risk score through EWG.org, EDTA is noted as commonly causing skin, eyes and lung irritations, and it may also be toxic to your organs.
Found in: hair color, moisturizers
Safer skin care product swaps: Beautycounter moisturizers (I'm a big fan of this one) and this mimosa body butter smells divine
13. MEA/DEA/TEA (also known as Ethanolamines)
These ingredients are surfactants (foam boosters) and pH adjusters. Currently, there has been limited scientific testing done with this ingredient family. That said, it's commonly linked to allergies, skin toxicity, hormone disruption, and inhibited fetal brain development.
Found in: hair dyes, mascara, foundation, fragrances, sunscreens
Safer skin care product swaps: my favorite volumizing mascara (the fluffy wand is incredible!), SPF 20 tinted moisturizer, tint skin foundation, mineral sunscreen lotion SPF 30, mineral sunscreen stick SPF 30, mineral sunscreen mist SPF 30
(Bonus points go to these sunscreens because they're also reef-safe!)
14. Hydroquinone
Hydroquinone is commonly found as an active ingredient in over-the-counter drugs. You'll also find it in fragrances and as a skin lightening chemical that inhibits the production of melanin. It's noted as an organ toxicity hazard and is also linked to cancer and skin irritations.
Most commonly found in: skin lightening creams
Safer skin care product swaps: use this brightening facial oil or overnight resurfacing peel if you're looking for a little extra glow
15. Methylisothiazolinone and Methylchloroisothiazolinone
These two ingredients are commonly found preservative ingredients in your skin care products. They're among the most common skin, eyes and lung irritants. They're also the culprit of many contact skin allergies.
Most commonly found in: shampoo, conditioner, body wash.
Safer skin care product swaps: daily shampoo, daily conditioner, citrus body wash
16. Toluene
Petrochemical solvent, pain thinning solution and…a common ingredient in nail polish. Toluene is linked to a number of contamination concerns, including skin, eyes and lung irritants, non-reproductive organ toxicity and it can also cause birth defects.
Most commonly found in: nail polish
Safer skin care product swaps: I like Coté nail polishes – this Adobe Clay shade is a great pseudo-neutral and they also have both a protective top / base and quick dry clear polishes
17. Lead
While lead occurs naturally in the environment, you'll also find this ingredient as an impurity in cosmetics like lipsticks, eye shadows, blushes, compact powders, shampoos, and even body lotions.
While the FDA is working to limit cosmetics deemed to have “unsafe” levels of lead, no safe blood lead level has actually been identified. There's also strong evidence that suggests that lead is a carcinogen. High lead levels can also damage people's kidneys, blood, and nervous system.
Bottom line: this is one of the most important skin care ingredients to avoid!
Most commonly found in: lipsticks, eye shadows, blushes, compact powders, shampoos, body lotions
Safer skin care product swaps: color intense lipsticks, velvet eyeshadow palette (this palette is my favorite!), nectar powder blush (it's just like NARS orgasm), mattifying powder, shampoo, mimosa body lotion, my favorite adaptive moisture lotion
18. Octinoxate
This is another common sunscreen ingredient no-no. Not only is octinoxate known for causing endocrine disruption, organ toxicity and cellular level changes, but it's also a suspected environmental pollutant. In fact, Hawaii has already moved ahead in banning this ingredient in sunscreens.
Most commonly found in: sunscreens
Safer skin care product swaps: mineral sunscreen mist SPF 30, mineral sunscreen lotion SPF 30, mineral sunscreen stick SPF 30,
19. Oxybenzone and Avobenzone
There's a lot to know about these common sunscreen ingredients. For instance, research links these to a wide variety of skin irritations, sensitization, and allergies, as well as being a possible hormone disruptor. And the FDA has noted that there are a number of data gaps with these ingredients as well.
The U.S. lists both of these among the 12 of 16 sunscreen filters allowed for use. That said, according to the agency, “nearly all of these [16] sunscreen active ingredients … have limited or no data characterizing their absorption.”
(And yet they continue to appear on sunscreen ingredient lists!)
Most commonly found in: sunscreen, moisturizer
Safer skin care product swaps: mineral sunscreen lotion SPF 30, mineral sunscreen stick SPF 30, mineral sunscreen mist SPF 30, mineral face SPF tinted moisturizer, moisturizers (my favorite is this one)
20. Benzalkonium Chloride
This ingredient is a disinfectant most often used as a preservative and surfactant. You're likely to find it in your household cleaning supplies, but it has also made its way into personal care products like deodorant and moisturizers. Research links this ingredient to severe skin, eye and respiratory irritation and allergies.
And if all of that wasn't bad enough, regular use of antimicrobials like this one could also lead to the development of resistant bacteria in your home.
Most commonly found in: deodorant, sunscreens, moisturizers
Safer skin care product swaps: natural deodorant (I like this one brand best – I use the charcoal version) mineral sunscreen lotion, mineral sunscreen stick, mineral sunscreen spray, moisturizers (this one is in regular rotation in my skincare regimen)
Conclusion
So, there you have it. These are the 20 skin care ingredients to avoid whenever I'm shopping for new skin care products and cosmetics. You also have my favorite clean product swaps. Selecting your products just got so much easier – I've done the ingredient fact-checking work for you!
Finally, I would highly recommend that you also bookmark the EWG cosmetics database if you're looking for even more comprehensive information about the skin care products sitting on your shelf.
Leave a Reply