And what to do if your coconut milk doesn't separate
Coconut whipped cream is one of the easiest recipes. You just refrigerate a can of full fat coconut milk and whip the coconut cream that separates and rises to the top. But what do you do if your can of coconut milk doesn't separate? I've tried many different brands of coconut milk. And even with my favorites, every once in a while I get a can that comes out of the refrigerator looking just like it did when it went in.
This happened to me on Thanksgiving. About an hour before dinner I opened my can of coconut milk to whip, and it was only partially separated. Since my family specifically requested whipped coconut cream to go with the paleo pumpkin pie, I knew I had to figure something out. I set a strainer over a bowl and lined it with a coffee filter. I added the slightly thickened coconut cream, leaving only the thin watery bit at the bottom of the can. And let it drain until it was the right consistency. Then I whipped the coconut cream as usual — it worked perfectly.
So now this is the trick I use to rescue my coconut whipped cream, if the coconut milk doesn't separate in the refrigerator.
- Open bottom of can of coconut milk and pour off liquid.
- Scoop separated coconut cream into large bowl and whip until it is the consistency of whipped cream.
- Add vanilla and honey to taste, and whip until combined.